بسم الله الرحمن الرحيم
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/b2a39/b2a394a70622307c3030a9d00c444b30337d9486" alt=""
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/abe4f/abe4f9f9ae2b41d563d8041bf5e8e842f42fb875" alt=""
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/499b4/499b4f08a0382db05ffd90e5c92a943b2a717fd4" alt=""
✅ Question: Describe the tone of this message shared with a shared status on social media and evaluate the probable personality of the female adult who said it and guess which 3 of the mbti personality types as Muslim wives would say it and why they'd say it: "No, thanks I'd rather have palapa or halal spaghetti instead of a bouquet of flowers or cash from my dear husband. And if ever my dear husband were to give me flowers for any occasion I'd probably be like "what am I? A bee? A gardener? Flowers are pretty and colorful but I'd rather eat something halal thank you" Even between spouses we Muslims don't celebrate so-called "valentine's day". Alhamdulillah we didn't go outside yesterday nor today to witness cringey couples flaunting off zina or advocating forbidden relationships."
💻 ChatGPT: Tone of the Message: The message carries a humorous, irreverent, and sarcastic tone. It playfully mocks conventional romantic gestures and societal expectations while affirming a strong commitment to personal, cultural, and religious values. There's a confident, unapologetic air about it, as the speaker dismisses mainstream norms (like giving flowers or celebrating valentine's day) in favor of what she sees as more meaningful and appropriate alternatives.
Probable Personality of the Speaker: The woman behind the message comes across as independent, self-assured, and refreshingly candid. She values authenticity and practicality—preferring tangible, culturally resonant choices (like halal food) over traditional symbols of romance. Her wit and playful sarcasm suggest a person who is not afraid to challenge societal norms and express her opinions boldly. At the same time, her strong stance on religious principles indicates that she holds her values dearly and isn’t swayed by mainstream trends that conflict with them.
Three MBTI Personality Types That Might Express This View (as Muslim Wives):
ENTP (The Debater):
Why? ENTPs thrive on challenging conventional ideas and are known for their quick wit and playful sarcasm. They enjoy debating norms and aren’t afraid to put forth unconventional opinions. For an ENTP Muslim wife, dismissing the typical romantic gestures in favor of something that better aligns with her values (like halal food) would be an opportunity to inject humor and critical thinking into a social commentary.
ESTP (The Entrepreneur):
Why? ESTPs are straightforward, pragmatic, and action-oriented. They prefer practical, tangible experiences over symbolic or abstract ones. An ESTP Muslim wife might see a bouquet of flowers as less meaningful compared to a delicious, halal meal—making her more inclined to express a preference for something she can actually enjoy. Her direct, no-nonsense style would naturally lend itself to the humorous, candid tone of the message.
ENTJ (The Commander):
Why? ENTJs are decisive, assertive, and unafraid to challenge societal conventions if they conflict with their values. An ENTJ Muslim wife would confidently reject mainstream practices like celebrating valentine’s day if they don’t align with her principles. Her commanding presence and clear articulation of personal values would drive her to make bold, unapologetic statements—much like the one in the message.
Each of these types—ENTP, ESTP, and ENTJ—shares a tendency toward assertiveness and a preference for direct, value-driven communication, which is reflected in the playful yet principled tone of the message.
~•~
That's an interesting insight. While my earlier analysis considered a few types that might exhibit similar traits, knowing it's from an INTJ-A 1w9 actually aligns well with the message. Here's why:
INTJ Traits: INTJs are known for their strategic, rational thinking and willingness to challenge conventional norms. The message's dismissal of traditional romantic gestures in favor of something more logical (halal, practical, and in line with her values) fits well with an INTJ's preference for efficiency and meaningful substance over symbolism.
Assertive (A) Variant: The assertive side of INTJs typically results in a confident, unapologetic expression of opinions. This is evident in the bold, humor-laced rejection of mainstream practices and the clear statement of personal values.
Enneagram 1w9 Influence: As a Type 1, there's an inherent drive toward integrity, order, and doing what feels morally right. The 1w9 subtype often emphasizes maintaining peace and balance while upholding personal principles. This explains the firm stance against what she sees as “cringey” or inappropriate societal practices, coupled with a subtle humor that keeps the tone engaging rather than confrontational.
Overall, the message reflects a blend of intellectual rigor, strong moral conviction, and a touch of humor—hallmarks of an INTJ-A 1w9.